As leaders, we often encounter situations where employees come to us with problems they expect us to solve.
Picture this: an employee enters your office and says, “Boss, I need your help. The other division isn’t responding to my emails about the data I need for my report.”
They stand there, waiting for you to provide an immediate solution.
While it’s tempting to jump in and resolve the issue quickly, this approach may actually (and inadvertently), hinder your employees’ growth and critical thinking skills.
The way we need to respond
Many managers complain that their team members lack initiative or struggle to think independently.
The root of this problem often lies in how we, as leaders, respond to these situations.
Instead of managing by providing ready-made solutions, consider adopting a coaching approach that fosters critical thinking.
This method not only empowers employees to solve problems independently, but also enhances their analytical and problem-solving abilities.
Our own research on leadership styles indicates that there are four fundamental leadership styles: Idealists, Diplomats, Stewards, and Pragmatists.
Of those, the Idealist is the one most inclined to adopt a coaching approach.
Idealists want to learn and grow, and they want everyone else to do the same.
They’re open-minded and prize creativity from themselves and others.
To adopt this kind of approach, here are four key questions you can use to stimulate critical thinking when an employee brings you a problem:
- “What steps have you taken so far to address this issue?”
- “What potential solutions are you considering?”
- “How do these ideas differ from your previous approaches?”
- “If your initial plan doesn’t work, what alternatives could you explore?”
By asking these questions, you’re guiding the employee through a critical thinking process that involves:
- Analyzing the current situation
- Generating potential solutions
- Evaluating different approaches
This coaching approach offers several benefits:
- It enhances critical thinking skills: Employees learn to break down problems, consider multiple perspectives, and evaluate potential outcomes.
- Promotes initiative: By guiding them through the problem-solving process, you’re teaching employees to take ownership of issues and to develop proactive mindsets.
- Reduces dependency: You avoid the trap of ‘reverse delegation,’ where employees consistently rely on you for solutions.
- Fosters innovation: Employees may surprise you with creative solutions that you hadn’t considered.
- Develops adaptability: As they practice critical thinking, employees become more adept at handling unforeseen challenges.
Obviously, there will be times when an urgent crisis requires a leader to jump in and forcefully say: “Here’s what you need to do, exactly this way, go do it now!”
But this highly-directive approach is sometimes necessary.
The problem is, that far too many leaders adopt this approach when a few minutes of coaching would offer no downside and plenty of upsides.
So, my message is this: encourage leaders in your organization to pause before delivering a direct solution.
Regularly employing a coaching approach will also yield long-term benefits. You’ll cultivate a team of independent thinkers who can tackle complex problems and adapt to changing circumstances.
The next time an employee brings you a problem, resist the urge to immediately offer a solution. Instead, guide them through the critical thinking process.
Not only will this approach save you time in the long run, but it will also help your team develop valuable skills that enhance their performance and job satisfaction.
Remember, the goal is not just to solve immediate problems but to build a workforce capable of navigating future challenges with confidence and creativity.